Washburn: “When Levels and Learning Clash: Moving from Levels to Supports in Designing
Instruction”
After reading “When Levels and Learning Clash: moving from levels to supports in designing
instruction,” I have to agree that we just can’t assume that success in
reading comes from leveling books for students. Based on my own observation
during reading time, interest and choice have deeper meaning than leveled
books. Learning comes to life when students first display interest in their
book of choice. By simply displaying interest in that book, it doesn’t matter
if this interest was ignited by the cover or the color of the book, students
begin to learn. Allowing them to have a choice in what they read (carefully
selected by us, but they don’t have to know that) will most likely result in
more relaxed outlook on reading. Reading, as Karen Johnson wrote in her blog,
should not be viewed as work.
Also, selecting books that are above their reading level
will work itself out, because students seem to go for those books, they are
risk takers, but we must let them be risk takers! If we pay attention to what
students really want out of books, we will find what they do not want. They
want freedom in the classroom, challenge and choices. By allowing them to read
books of their choice and above their reading level, we are letting them know
that we have faith in them as responsible readers. If they feel responsible,
they feel happy, and when they are happy, they learn.
You make a great point. We don't want to make reading turn into work. It is important to look beyond levels. Your observations of students while reading is paying off since you notice that interest and choice are driving factors for your students. Allowing that when possible in your classroom will help them explore more texts and hopefully ignite their love of reading.
ReplyDeleteHi Mascha,
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that our students benefit from choice. Don't we all want ownership over our learning and options when it comes to our application? Our students are no different and when we provide them with choice for their independent reading we know that it increases their motivation and their engagement with the text, especially when their choices are supported by the instruction and purposes their teacher establishes for their reading. Thank you! Dawn