A phrase that stood out
for me was “The current emphasis on word calling, automaticity, and fluency in
the early grades is often at the expense of understanding.” I agree with this
and it reminds me to put more emphasis on students’ comprehension and not just
reading fluency. The strategies on page 118 that “have been identified as being
key for achieving full understanding when we read” is another reminder for me
to model these strategies so students would use them. On page 119, the author
writes that “In many cases, what gets left out is enough time for the
independent reading that enables students to use and practice these
strategies.” This is so true! I was once reminded on page 122, that teachers
“need to take care not just to model individual strategies in isolation and
hope for a transfer of learning.” Page 129 summarizes this chapter very well
“We must take care that teaching a particular strategy does not take precedence
over reading and understanding text.”
Hi Lyuda,
ReplyDeleteI like the quote you ended your blog post with from Routman's chapter on comprehension about the importance of not teaching strategies in isolation at the cost of overall comprehension of the text. She makes a great point that if we believe reading is meaning then we can't separate skills and strategies without providing opportunities for students to apply and see them applied in the context of actual reading.